If you want to start with something new, you have to start in small scale but with the real technology. Can "faux letterpress" let you manage pressure, for instance? I dont' think so, but I don't know "faux letterpress", honestly. Without pressure you are far from letterpress, you only have letters. Letterpress was (and is) about fine tuning the pressure to let ink just "kiss" the paper. Today letterpress uses higher pressure to have really visible impressions. But pressure is always a fundamental aspect. So, I would go with Adana, or another actual letterpress.
Hotstamping — another popular at-home method — lets you control heat level, pressure, and dwell time. That should be able to mimic the process. I think in a way they are related processes, but the big difference is foil vs. ink. I know, all the letterpress purists must be shaking their heads in dismay, 'No way are they related!'. Just sayin'. I never really thought about using hotstamp to mimic letterpress though. The end result is just different. I've noticed letterpress can do very fine lines and small type, while hotstamping tends to struggle with this.
The Adana press is a nice press. I agree with Maurizio: buy a real press. There are things you will be able to do in the Adana, both in make-ready, registration, and printing that you will not be able to do with the Faux letterpress or that thing you can get from Paper Source. Be careful though there are pitfalls to the smaller hand presses, too. Especially with the box car base: it will limit the size of work you can do, and also the box car bases are known for smashing gauge pins when trying to print final size sheets on a small press like the Adana. We usually print on an oversize sheet and trim out to final size.
I am not a big fan of faux anything. In fact I still cringe when I see Photoshop effects called "letterpress." I agree that you would be better off investing and learning on a small real letterpress like a Chandler and Price. There are an abundance of 10" × 15" or 8" × 12" out there that can be had fairly cheaply. You can get rollers for them and they are not too difficult to move and to learn to run.
Editor of FPO and co-founder of UnderConsideration LLC.
More: Online / On Twitter
FPO (For Print Only), is a division of UnderConsideration, celebrating the reality that print is not dead by showcasing the most compelling printed projects.
FPO uses Fonts.com to render Siseriff and Avenir Next.
FPO is run with Six Apart’s MovableType
All comments, ideas and thoughts on FPO are property of their authors; reproduction without the author’s or FPO’s permission is strictly prohibited
Twitter @ucllc
Mailing list managed by MailChimp
UnderConsideration is a graphic design firm generating its own projects, initiatives, and content while taking on limited client work. Run by Bryony Gomez-Palacio and Armin Vit in Bloomington, IN. More…
blogs we publish
Brand New / Displaying opinions and focusing solely on corporate and brand identity work.
Art of the Menu / Cataloguing the underrated creativity of menus from around the world.
Quipsologies / Chronicling the most curious, creative, and notable projects, stories, and events of the graphic design industry on a daily basis.
products we sell
Flaunt: Designing effective, compelling and memorable portfolios of creative work.
Brand New Conference videos / Individual, downloadable videos of every presentation since 2010.
Prints / A variety of posters, the majority from our AIforGA series.
Other / Various one-off products.
events we organize
Brand New Conference / A two-day event on corporate and brand identity with some of today's most active and influential practitioners from around the world.
Brand Nieuwe Conference / Ditto but in Amsterdam.
Austin Initiative for Graphic Awesomeness / A speaker series in Austin, TX, featuring some of the graphic design industry's most awesome people.
also
Favorite Things we've Made / In our capacity as graphic designers.
Projects we've Concluded / Long- and short-lived efforts.
UCllc News / Updates on what's going at the corporate level of UnderConsideration.
Related entries
I would like to print a psychedelic looking business card where one side changes color, similar to an oil rainbow (see picture below).
Ask the Experts #11
Is it possible to letterpress a 10-foot or more continuous piece of paper that later could be folded?
Ask the Experts #10
We are having trouble with the ink of a PMS setting right on GF Smith Plike. Does anyone have experience printing a solid on this paper or should I look at another stock?
Ask the Experts #9
Would it be possible to print offset printing (CMYK Process colors) on uncoated brown paper? And will the ink show? Alternately: what is the best way of printing light colors on dark stock?
Ask the Experts #7