One of my classes is the last graphic design class for seniors at East Carolina University so the subject of portfolios inevitably comes up. I told them that they would probably want several variations of portfolios—a website, an electronic portfolio on disk that they can mail or leave, and what one would have traditionally thought of as a portfolio. But what is that last thing?
If you hire designers, what observations do you have about the form of the portfolios you look at? Are handcraft and interesting binding impressive or distractions? Are boards the flexible way to arrange work while showing the proper respect or a clumsy pain? Can a well-maintained collection of loose pieces allow you to feel what opening a book or brochure really feels like for the reader or does that just seem sloppy and overly casual?
What do people do with their portfolios that impress you and what (other than the quality of the work shown) makes you want to shut them and scream “leave me alone!”?
If you have been looking for work, what reactions have you seen to the structure of your portfolio (as opposed to the quality of the work shown)? What have you found most useful and what have you discovered is a waste of time?
Do you end up dropping off your portfolio? FedExing it? Just emailing a URL? Is the portfolio you send or leave the same as the one you carry for an interview?
If you hire designers, what about smaller samples? Is it effective to get postcards mailed to you? PDFs emailed to you?
Everyone,do you have any portfolio war stories you’d like to share?
I think it would be helpful to everyone if you noted what role you have in portfolio use (i.e., do you hire employees or freelancers, have you been looking for a job or freelance work, etc.)
I've been showing work to potential clients, peers, and to instructors for feedback. I do it all on screen.
I find that I don't get awarded jobs based on print quality, paper texture. I get and hold interest when I frame the problems and explain my solutions. The "portfolio" becomes a visual accompaniment to a well-articulated end of a conversation with the person on the other side of the table.
For a while, full-screen PDF presentations were sufficient. Now I find Keynote best, because motion work, audio, videos, and web links are easily maintained and integrated.
I've consistently hear from showing work this way that the viewer was impressed with how organized and together the presentation was. I usually put in blank slide before pieces that need an extended setup. This way, I mantain attention on what I'm saying, then reveal the piece. No one has ever indicated that they wish they were in control of the process. In fact, some appreciated not having to "work" to review. There isn't any awkward board shuffling or page-flipping.
On Jan.26.2006 at 11:35 AM